From the day Urban Decay’s Naked eyeshadow palette hit the scene, nude makeup palettes became the beauty equivalent of our go-to black boots. Which is to say, we use them daily, they go with everything, and we’ll never, ever stop looking at new ones. There are so few downsides: Neutral eyeshadow palettes toe the line between practical and sexy (thank you, brown smoky eyes), fly at work and on the weekend, and make eye shadow so easy it’s impossible to mess up. The only downside? Our love runs too deep. Every time we walk into Sephora, the drugstore, or anywhere palettes are sold, we gravitate toward the neutrals we know look great. And when every brand has its own spin on the perfect nude eye shadow palette, that creates some incredibly tough choices. To help narrow it down, we had our editors give the top options a test run. Here’s what we came away obsessed with.