Let’s be honest: Eyeshadow palettes are where some shades go to die. You know the ones—bold, intimidating, seemingly obscure colors that are left virtually untouched, while a select few (we’re looking at you suits-every-occasion bronzey brown) hits pan every single time. This fall, though, jewel tones are coming in strong, and with them, an urge to swap safe shades for vibrant amethyst, sapphire, and ruby. To prove that there’s a cool way to work every single shadow into your makeup rotation, we gave four beauty pros our favorite new compact from Lancôme’s collaboration with Proenza Schouler (out this September)—and let them go wild. Here’s how to cop each look.