PHOTO: Courtesy of Netflix

It’s been just short of a year since we heard the infamous Last Four Words at the end of the Gilmore Girls revival, when Rory told Lorelai, “I’m pregnant.” In that moment, the world was split into their respective teams— that is, Teams Logan, Jess, or Dean. (Of course, there was also that guy in the Wookie costume who we’d rather forget.) And while the debate still rages on—though it’s been officially announced that Jess is not the father, per Milo Ventimiglia’s insider knowledge—we still don’t have an answer. But it turns out Tanc Sade and Alan Loayza, who played Colin and Finn (a.k.a. Rory’s classmates and Logan’s best friends), have an idea.

The actors made an appearance at the Gilmore Girls Fan Fest in Kent, Connecticut, on Saturday. They spoke on a panel about the Life & Death Brigade—you know, the secret society at Yale that jumps off of buildings and speaks only using words that don’t have the letter E.

When they were asked about who they think the father of Rory’s baby could be, according to Bustle, Sade pointed at himself and laughed before Loayza stated, “It’s gotta be Logan.”

Why does he think so? “That’s purely from a selfish standpoint, because we would be the uncles. So if they bring it back, we would be doing crazy uncle stuff and probably putting the baby in some Life & Death Brigade adventures… A little mini umbrella for the baby,” Loayza explained.

So…maybe not the best reasoning.

Obviously, this is all speculation: these two Life & Death Brigaders don’t have any official word on who it is. Loayza admits, however, that he still thinks it could possibly be Jess. “That was the one thing that I thought like, if [Amy Sherman-Palladino] was going to throw a curveball, maybe with that look when [Jess] looks at [Rory] at the end. Did a moment happen after the newspaper scene between them that we never saw? We don’t know.”

They also opened up about which of Rory’s old flames they prefer. Loayza has worked with both Ventimiglia and Jared Padalecki who played Dean outside of Gilmore Girls. “But, in the world, I think I am Team Logan,” he admitted. We understand the unwavering support of their bestie, but frankly, we still need closure.

Related Stories:
–Milo Ventimiglia Knows Who Isn’t the Father of Rory’s Baby on ‘Gilmore Girls’
–This ‘Gilmore Girls’ Theory Suggests Rory and Logan Are the New Emily and Richard
–Milo Ventimiglia’s ‘Gilmore Girls’ Theory About the Father of Rory’s Baby Might Enrage You