While the rise of eyelash extensions, lifts, and tints have changed the lash game for good, there’s still a case to be made for mascara. You can pick up a tube anywhere, it takes your lashes from zero to 100 in mere seconds (as opposed to hour long treatments), and can cost less than a latte. Plus, the best lengthening mascaras out there will give you lashes just as long as extensions without all the fuss, you just need to know where to look for them.

Our editors swiped and tested their way through dozens of options to narrow down 15 that honestly deliver long, fluttery, Bambi-level lashes. From waterproof formulas to drugstore gems, there’s something for everyone. Read on for the best lengthening mascaras Glamour editors can’t live without now.