“Godzilla: King of the Monsters” has a sense of wonder. After I left the screening late at night and emerged onto a dark city street at nearly one a.m., I wanted to look up rather than straight ahead, just in case Ghidorah the three-headed dragon or Rodan the giant pterodactyl came screaming down from the clouds. That’s not the same thing as saying this is a perfect movie. It’s far from that. But its errors fall mainly under the heading of failing to get out of its own way, and its imperfections are compensated by magnificence.
Directed and cowritten by Michael Dougherty (“Krampus“), the movie follows on the heels of the 2014 “Godzilla” and the 2017 “Kong: Skull Island.” It’s conceived as part of a shamelessly Marvel-styled “shared cinematic universe” of stories that interlink and gradually build towards a series of peaks (the first of which is 2020’s “Godzilla vs. Kong”). The human heroes are part of a top-secret project called the Monarch Initiative. This mythology visualizes Godzilla and the other giant monsters made famous by Toho studios, including Ghidorah, Rodan, Mothra, and King Kong (an American creation folded into that universe) as part of an ancient ecosystem of long-hibernating giant monsters that predate the dinosaurs. They can travel from one part of the globe to the other quickly via tunnels through the center of the planet (this is what’s known as “Hollow Earth theory”). They are emerging now in response to humanity’s despoiling of the environment through atomic testing, nuclear and chemical waste-dumping, mountaintop demolition mining, and other practices that amount to assaults on Mother Earth.
This Hollywood-financed American series is an internationalization of original Toho Studios-produced Godzilla pictures, with a correspondingly international cast, all representing different takes on the monster problem, such as it is. There are appearances by characters from the 2014 film, including a couple of monster specialists played by Ken Wantanabe and Sally Hawkins, but the main characters are a fractured nuclear family, consisting of two Monarch project scientists, Doctors Mark and Emma Russell (Kyle Chandler and Vera Farmiga) and their teenage daughter Madison (“Stranger Things” star Millie Bobbie Brown). They lost the fourth member of their family, Madison’s older brother, five years earlier during Godzilla’s battle with the MUTOs in San Francisco, and the parents ultimately separated. It soon becomes clear that the split was equally due to grief and a philosophical disagreement over how to deal with Godzilla and his ilk—the father thinks they should all be exterminated, while mom believes they can be manipulated through a special sonar device that mimics the dynamics of whale songs.
At least that’s our impression of the mother, but everyone in the family (indeed everyone on the planet, probably) is dealing with the monster problem in their own emotional way, and some of them are secretly or not-so-secretly destructive. The openly destructive contingent is defined by Charles Dance’s Colonel Alan Jonah, a former British Special Forces veteran turned eco-terrorist who seems to believe that the monsters are punishment for humanity’s sins against the environment and is working to awaken as many of the hibernating beasts as possible, the better to hasten the thinning of the human herd. As revealed early in the film (as well as in all the teasers and trailers), Emma is on board with Jonah’s take on things, and actively participates in waking up the beasts—including Ghidorah, a lightning-spitting dragon who represents the only serious threat to Godzilla’s position as the Hollow Earth’s apex predator.
One of the fascinations of this film is the way it treats the monsters as outward manifestations of the characters’ personal issues, at times like enormous dopplegangers or golems representing their grief, trauma, post-traumatic stress disorder. But in addition to the individual grief being experienced by the characters, “King of the Monsters” is suffused with grief for what might be the impending death of human civilization itself, which according to real scientists is a certainty if we don’t turn our environmental act around over the next hundred years or so. Jonah and Emma are quite explicit (too explicit; this is a talky film when it’s not blowing stuff up) in their belief that the human species has, via inattention and greed, become bystanders in the drama of its own extinction—and that we might as well go ahead and speed things up with a little help from Godzilla, Ghidorah and company, since that’s what the planet itself needs, and what humans deserve.
Emma even compares human civilization to a virus, and the monsters to a “fever” that could wipe most of it out and restore biological balance. A sort of compacted TED Talk in the middle of the film even reveals that once the monsters have finished fighting, and depart the ruins of a city, the radiation they leave behind acts as a biological accelerant, activating the rapid growth of plant and animal life that all the concrete, glass and steel once restrained or destroyed.
But at what price balance? That’s the big question, the Thanos of it all. The great Ghidorah—frozen in a wall of ice in deep underground in an Antarctica-based Monarch facility, and looking like the biggest, baddest art installation of all time—is this film’s equivalent of the extinction-level threat, the fever bomb who’s fated to burn through the human virus. Dougherty and his army of designers and special effects people do a great job of building up Ghidorah as if he (it?) is an ancient and unstoppable evil force whose very name fills the human heart with dread, even envisioning him as a Voldemort-like threat, the dragon whose name can’t be spoken (he’s also called Monster Zero, shades of Patient Zero) and whose image must be distorted, because to picture him exactly is to summon him. (A selection of past artwork allegedly depicting Ghidorah includes William Blake’s painting “The Great Red Dragon and Woman Clothed in Sun,” also a fixture in Hannibal Lecter stories).
Gareth Edwards’ franchise’-starting “Godzilla” was a huge International hit, but divided viewers because of its flat, action figure-like characterizations, its meticulous, almost “Jaws“-like unveiling of Godzilla and the two Massive Unidentified Terrestrial Objects (MUTOs) that he ended up fighting, and its relative dearth of actual Godzilla footage (about seven minutes). The movie also placed the big fella within the larger ecosystem of wolves and snakes and birds and such. It contained more nature footage than you expected to see in a city-stomping kaiju epic, to the point where you half-expected Terrence Malick shots of honey-tinted fields and perhaps a narration by Godzilla (“Fire…water…why do you wrestle inside me?”). There were fears (among those who loved the original) and hopes (among people who hated it) that future movies would offer less philosophizing and atmospheric indulgences and more footage of giant monsters beating the tar out of each other, and the Vietnam-era period piece “Kong: Skull Island” delivered plenty, pitting the now super-sized ape against a series of Lovecraftian giants that seemed to be half-insect, half-demon, and making sure that the story didn’t go five minutes without a burst of violent spectacle.
“King of the Monsters” tries to blend the two approaches, not always successfully, and it suffers mightily from its inability to trust the audience to understand both the substance and implications of the action that it presents so boldly and intelligently onscreen. This movie is a succession of miracles and cursed disasters, wheeled or unfurled onscreen with dazzling showmanship and plenty of overscaled grace notes, from the way Rodan chases and catches an F-14 fighter jet and bits off its nose cone like a hawk beheading a sparrow, to the way Ghidorah’s three heads talk and whisper to each other, and at times even abuse each other, like the Three Stooges treating slaps as the continuation of conversation. (The middle head is Moe, the other two are Larry and Curly.) The constant need to summarize and annotate every significant moment grows wearisome (it’s like being stuck watching a sporting event with a couple of sportscasters who don’t know when to shut up) but at the level of image, sound and music, this is a frequently brilliant film: simultaneously real science fiction that earnestly grapples with the ideas it presents, and a religious picture about faith and spirituality, sin and redemption, where monsters die for our sins so that humankind won’t have to.