Categories
TV & Movies

Indian Point


Thumb_indian-point-2016

One of the first people the viewer meets in “Indian Point”
is Brian Vangor, a nuclear engineer who’s been working at the Indian Point
Energy Center, a nuclear power plant, for almost 40 years. Vangor is, as
nuclear power plant workers go, kind of the anti-Homer Simpson. Soft-spoken,
knowledgeable, conscientious, calm. He is the Senior Control Room Operator at
the plant and he seems to know well what he’s on about. He’s the kind of guy,
in other words, who you definitely want overseeing such an operation. And he
believes in what he does. “This technology has its problems,” he asserts, “But show me a technology that doesn’t.”

Of course, the potential problems of nuclear energy are
decidedly different from any other form of energy. This point was brought home
by the multiple meltdowns at Japan’s Fukushima plant after an earthquake and
attendant tsunami in 2011. Japan, and the world, is still feeling the effects
of that disaster, and the event gave new motivation and energy to the residents
of the town Indian Point. Just thirty miles away from the New York metropolitan
area, the Indian Point plant is operated by a company called Entergy, and its
license was up for renewal shortly after the Fukushima event. Writer/director Ivy Meerpool’s
engrossing documentary profiles local activists and journalists—in this case,
specifically, an activist and a journalist who are also a married couple—while looking
at the bigger picture via the story of Gregory Jaczko, the onetime head of the
Nuclear Regulatory Commission who, by this movie’s reckoning, was forced out of
his position by a ginned-up scandal after his post-Fukushima recommendations
for safety chafed the actual energy industry.

Meerpool’s movie is scary without being alarmist; it notes,
of course, the fact that Indian Point has operated without a Fukushima type
event for over two decades, but it also quietly says that SHOULD a Fukushima
type event ever occur there, I myself probably won’t be around to write a
review that’s critical of nuclear energy. While the profiles of folks like
Vangor provide a certain even-handedness, the movie does have an agenda, and
it’s helped when someone like Jim Steets, the spokesman for Entergy, shows up
on screen. He’s very professional, maybe too professional: were one in the mood
to be unkind, one would note that his whole manner practically screams
“corporate hack” in mere nanoseconds.

Jaczko, on the other hand, is portrayed as a conscientious
public servant whose initial mission was hardly to rule out the nuclear option,
but who is persuaded by what he witnesses in Japan to say, at one point, “Maybe
[we need to] shut down all the plants.” Interesting idea, given that there are
almost 450 online in the world now.

Even as it evokes terrifying dangers, the movie holds out
hope. As Jaczko points out, even as space-age energy goes, nuclear is pretty
old-school and probably on the way out. On the other hand, the energy industry
as it’s currently constituted is digging its heels in: it wants what it wants,
and productively moving forward is not really a priority. This, combined with
things such as “spent fuel pools,” which this movie describes in some
disquieting details, are invoked by the filmmakers to send a message to the
viewer: change isn’t going to happen without constant citizen vigilance and
activism. 



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.