There’s a scene midway through Shane Black’s fun “The Nice
Guys” in which Ryan Gosling’s truly mediocre private investigator has stumbled
down a hill, drunkenly trying to impress a girl at a party. As he will do
several times in the film, he literally falls into a clue, a rotting corpse of
someone he’s been looking for. And what does
Gosling do when he comes face to face with it? He doesn’t respond in the typically
nonchalant movie star way. No, he digs much deeper into the comedy movie bag of
tricks and pulls out, of all things, a Lou Costello impression—that wonderful,
silent scream the actor would do when he saw something like the Wolfman. It is a truly hysterical moment, one of several bits
of physical comedy that Gosling pulls off throughout “The
Nice Guys.” Combined with the excellent straight man work by Russell Crowe, the
two actors become a surprisingly brilliant comedy duo, carrying “The Nice Guys”
past a few flat jokes, needed edits and a cluttered finale.
Gosling plays Holland March, a pretty pathetic P.I.
whose wife died in a house explosion, leaving him with an alcohol problem and
the sole parenting job of 13-year-old Holly (the naturally gifted Angourie
Rice). March is hired to find a porn star named Misty Mountains, who we know
died in a car accident. In the film’s opening scene, a kid waits until his parents are
asleep and pulls out a porno mag, gazing lovingly at the centerfold model, revealed to be Ms. Mountains. Just then, a car comes careening through his house
and down the L.A. hillside. The kid stumbles to the car to find Misty herself
splayed out in much the same position she was in the centerfold, but she’s
bloody and dying. He covers her up. From the beginning, Black starts developing
the theme of a dark world in which the “nice guys” muster as much decency as
possible, even if it’s covering up the body of someone you were ogling minutes
before.
March’s search for Misty leads him to try and track down
someone who worked on a porno with her recently, Amelia (Margaret Qualley), who
happens to have hired a muscle guy named Jackson Healy (Crowe) to protect her. Healy
is a level below your typical City of Angels P.I., the kind of guy who you hire
to send a message with brass knuckles more than to find someone. And so he
conveys the message to March that he should stop looking for Amelia. When they
realize something very strange is going on with the dead-not-dead porn star and
everyone else involved with a particular adult production, March and Healy team
up in a very Shane Black style. This is the writer and director who redefined the buddy action
comedy when he wrote “Lethal Weapon,” although this particular piece has more
in common with his underrated directorial effort “Kiss Kiss Bang Bang.”
“The Nice Guys” is a dark comedy that takes place in a time in
which Kennedy is dead, poverty is on the rise, corruption is rampant, the Hollywood sign is falling down and porn
is as successful as the auto industry (I love the parallel party sequences, one
celebrating adult film and one celebrating car manufacturers … they look nearly identical other than the degree of nudity). It’s really
about people trying to keep their heads above rising waters, and what it takes
to maintain some semblance of decency in an increasingly indecent world. And
yet Black is smart enough to not make his leading men into saints. Healy is a
blunt instrument, a man who gets the job done and gets out, but he’s also got a
sense of what he should and should not do for a paying client. He’ll break your arm, but he’s breaking your arm for a reason. March is an alcoholic without much desire to
fix that particular problem today; there are more pressing ones. One of the
operating beliefs of the film could be summed up when Healy says heroically, “We’re
gonna hunt down the people who did it,” and March chimes in with a perfectly
timed, “for a deeply discounted rate.” Everybody in this cesspool of a city gets
a cut, even the good guys, as set in a time period when a 13-year-old can be the only remaining, decent voice of reason.
The cast is perfect, but “The Nice Guys” could have used one more rewrite or two and
another trip to the editing bay to really streamline jokes that don’t work
and a plot that gets more cluttered than engaging. It’s not until an actual
villain (Matt Bomer) shows up more than an hour into the piece that you realize
that the movie didn’t have one before then (although one could argue the
entire city of L.A. is the bad guy). And some of the bits get repetitive before the
movie’s over. We know that Holly is the brains, Healy is the brawn and March is
the bumbling hero that ties them together before this trio figures it out for
themselves, and I wish the film had another surprise up its sleeve, a narrative
turn that felt fresher than the inevitable Shane Black Shootout waiting in the
climax.
Having said that, what I think people will underrate the
most about “The Nice Guys” is the choreography of the entire piece.
Without spoiling specific details, the final sequence features Gosling chasing
something and falling on car hoods, into windshields, and over his own two
feet. He’s far from the suave hero you’ll see in a dozen other summer
blockbusters this year. And Gosling completely sells it, as he does throughout the
entire film. He may not be the hero that L.A. needs in the ’70s, but he’s the hero that L.A.’s got in the ’70s. And it’s his gift for slapstick, combined with his fantastic chemistry with Crowe, that makes these “Nice Guys” worth a look. Unlike most comedies in recent memory, I’d gladly watch another adventure with these three characters front and center. Maybe they’ll finally catch a break.