![]()
“Norman Lear: Just Another Version of You” is a biography of
one of TV’s most influential producers, and an influential American, period:
the creator of “All in the Family,” “Maude,” “Good Times” and “The
Jeffersons,” and the founder of the liberal activist group People for the
American Way, which was founded as a response against evangelical activists to
reclaim patriotism for the left. But while the film works as a primer
for viewers who are curious about Lear but don’t know the details of his life
and work, it’s more interesting as a movie about age and memory. Lear was 92
when the film was shot during a book tour last year, and while he’s as mentally
and physically active as a person could hope to be at his age, the movie is
suffused with melancholy, much of it stemming from Lear’s realization that most
of his life is behind him.
Perhaps not coincidentally, it’s a film about faces. Most of
Lear’s triumphs were in the 1970s: “All in the Family,” a politically-charged
sitcom based on the English series “Till Death Us Do Part,” debuted in CBS in
1971, when the Vietnam War, the antiwar movement, and the feminist, gay rights
and Civil Rights movements were still powerfully active. The movie is filled
with shots of Lear on the sets of these shows, leading script readings and
consulting with actors, looking fit and alert and slim, and always clad in his
trademark fedora.
The documentary’s co-directors, Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady,
shoot Lear in the present day with the sort of tender regard you might
lavish on a grandparent if you had feature film-quality cameras and lighting
and your grandparent didn’t mind being followed around by a movie crew. Their camera moves in close on Lear as he talks about his
successes and controversies in American television, his collaborations with
writers and actors, and his battles with network executives and censors over
the political content of his shows, which resembled political debates as often
as they did farcical family spats.
The moviemakers shoot some of Lear’s friends and
collaborators, including “All in the Family” co-star and future feature director
Rob Reiner and “Good Times” star John Amos, with just as much affection. All the
images of deeply lined faces would be powerful on their own, but when they’re
juxtaposed with shots of their younger selves—often being projected on a large
screen while the older versions watch—the effect is magical: cinema as time
machine. At various points they are all watching what amounts to the movie of
their lives. The longest one is about Lear, who trips back through his own past
with the filmmakers’ guidance, riffing on memories, telling stories, and
tearing up at the sight of old friends who died a long time ago. The most
touching sequences feature “All in the Family” star Carroll O’Connor, who
played the bigoted working-class Irish-American Archie Bunker. Lear
acknowledges that Archie is a version of his own father, and weeps while
viewing the memorable episode where Archie describes his dad, a bigot who beat
his values into his son, as a great man and a loving parent.
Jumping off from an early statement by Lear about how much
he loves the magic of theater, the directors place him and the other
present-day witnesses on a soundstage that suggests a set from an unproduced,
off-Broadway multimedia drama. Interviewees are surrounded by significant life-props
(including Lear’s trademark hat on a coat rack), hanging screens, movie lights
and other theatrical and filmmaking paraphernalia, all clearly visible in the
frame. The effect is reminiscent of the framing sequences in Bob Fosse’s “All
that Jazz,” where the hero tried to seduce the Angel of Death while
contemplating the arc of his life. There’s even a child version of Lear on
hand, played by a young actor. This “Afterlife Café” set is the core of the film.
The yellowed family photos, newspaper clippings and home movie and interview
footage—stretching back through the 1960s and sometimes earlier—seem to radiate
out from it.
The directors build out this Proustian notion by cutting
from the present to the past without warning, as when Lear rides an elevated
train through Upper Manhattan, glances out the window and sees train footage
from that same train line when he was a boy. It’s all rather arty for what is
ultimately a showbiz documentary about a famous TV producer, but while the
time-machine technique doesn’t always feel necessary or right (sometimes you
just want to hear people talking about what they saw and did and lose the other
stuff) at least it’s a thoughtful attempt to give viewers an honest-to-goodness
artistic portrait of Lear—an artistic representation of an artist, as opposed
to a data dump that the audience could just as easily get by staying home and
reading Wikipedia.
Unfortunately, these poetic effects often come at the
expense of the basics. There are puzzling lapses in reporting: we learn, for
example, that Lear’s vagabond con-man of a father went to jail when he was nine
and that his absence devastated the boy, contributing to his lifelong
distrust of father figures and authority, but we never learn what, exactly, the
elder Lear was charged with, how long he was behind bars, or what
eventually became of him. Later, Lear talks with agonized honesty about the
collapse of his first marriage to Frances Lear, who was mentally ill; the
anecdote ends with Lear searching her out after she disappeared and finding her
on the floor of an apartment, but we never find out exactly what became of her.
These gaps and others are frustrating because they seem as
if they could have filled without much trouble, and because the screen time
they might have occupied is often filled up with scenes that feel like budget
Fellini. The sequences dealing with the classic sitcoms are a bit frustrating,
too, cutting away just when they seem to be building up a rhetorical
head of steam; this is particularly noticeable in the “Good Times” and “The
Jeffersons” sequences, which open up a can of worms related to race and
representation that the film doesn’t quite know how to deal with.
Still, this is a striking piece of work. Lear is a great
camera subject, a brilliant storyteller and so emotionally transparent that
you might not mind if he went on for another half-hour—as long as it meant
that you got to hear him talk some more, or watch him sit and think, or tear
up over images of people who meant something to him.